Skip to main content

Is "Venky" India's Nobel laureate?


Photo courtesy: telegraph.co.uk

SUDDENLY, everyone is claiming "ownership" of (or affiliation to) the 2009 Chemistry Nobel laureate Venkatraman ("Venky") Ramakrishnan. The press in India. The town where he was born. The state where this town is located. The town in another state where he lived. The university, where he completed his undergraduation. The universities, where he made presentations ... the list goes on ...

Venky, however, left India some four decades ago and received significant education and a culture/environment (for such work) in the US and UK.

There are brilliant Indians like Venky. However, are there institutions/companies in India that can encourage/enable the Venky kind of world-impacting work? If not, is it alright to make claims such as we've seen since the announcement of the Chemistry Nobel prize? And, why were the claims made only after an Award was announced? Why did they not celebrate Venky's great work earlier? As Venky himself asks (reported in The Times of India, October 8, 2009), "None of you called me about my work even two days ago, right?"

Only when celebration of the WORK becomes part of the culture, celebration of a subsequent award becomes a natural and accepted thing to do.

Comments

  1. You missed the most hilarious bit...I have seen forwarded emails saying he is the third tamil IYER to win a Nobel prize!!! This is just so ridiculous!

    Venky himself answered some of your other questions. He said that Indians are too obsessed with Nobel and such western prizes. He also said India has good places to do research (and it appears he was not just being polite) but maybe not the kind of high cost high investment fundamental research which India cannot afford and for which there is no culture in India. Indian Scientists are doing good work in areas that impact India significantly (like M S Swaminathan in Agriculture) and we should try to encourage them with more funding and support.

    Even now for a layman like me, it is hard to understand the implications what Venky was researching, so I dont blame the press for not writing a story about it before he won the Nobel prize. Now, he has a chance to explain to the world the significance of his work so that people can understand his achievement. I dont see anything wrong with that.

    ReplyDelete
  2. If the country's CULTURE instead has a focus on celebrating good work, claims to ownership/affiliation will not be perceived as "COMMERCIALLY" motivated.

    ReplyDelete
  3. That the thing about us...We are overwhelmed when any thing remotely related to India gets recognized. Be it VS Naipaul(who said he is not Indiam, Bobby Jindal(no way an Indian) and now Venky. He no more an Indian citizen ...we should celebrate his achievement like other two. Why to be obsessed with something which is not yours and be humiliated by it. Obviously Venky is not so proud about his origin.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Sequence of possible "events":

    1. India: Perhaps did not celebrate or recognize his WORK all these years

    2. Venky: Probably annoyed (to put it mildly) with that attitude

    3. India: Suddenly claims ownership/affiliation when someone ABROAD recognizes and gives an Award

    4: Venky: May have seen the sudden "love" from India as opportunistic or delayed

    5: India: Reacts by judging him as EQ-deficient and challenging him with "You will one day hunger for India" (The Times of India October 20, 2009 article "EQ versus IQ").

    If the above "events" are true, then you know what needs to change: CULTURE!

    ReplyDelete
  5. @Ranjan: I dont think Venky said or did anything that indicated he is not proud about his origin. He, in fact, said Indians and Indian institutes are doing great work. I dont know how you came to your conclusion.

    @Pradeep: It is wrong to conclude Indian Culture is judging him as EQ- deficient just because a POLITICIAN Abhishek Singhvi wrote it...

    I also wont jump to judging Indian culture just because of what we read in the generally loud and sensationalist media. Indian culture has always encouraged education, science and learning and enquiry which is how we have created a large pool of educated talent in India which has built the IT industry for example.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Thanks for your comments. And ... oh, we're not talking about picking up degrees (= education? = learning?) which certainly is part of the culture and is good ... we're talking about being DIFFERENT (challenging the Status quo) and being CELEBRATED for being different (regardless of the outcomes) :-)

    ReplyDelete
  7. The idea of the "Power of NEW" blog and my own personal/career "mission" are to help IMPROVE things ... In other words, it's about making Change happen ... Change in terms of Thinking ... Attitudes ... Behaviors ... Methods ... Processes ... Values ... Unfortunately, I might not applaud the status quo (there are lots of people doing that already). In fact, I might "punish" people who love the Status quo (that should change). And making it all even "worse," my language could be politically incorrect at times (I did not grow up reading Peter Drucker ... I grew up reading Tom Peters!). But, I hope you see some value in all this ... someone, somewhere might CHANGE. Hope you would join me in this "movement"!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Business model intimacy

Courtesy: NobelPrize.org
The Grameen Bank success story continues to be researched and written about. Other companies have tried to repeat the Bank's model. Is there a fundamental difference between the original innovation and the followers? In MIT Sloan Management Review (Summer 2009), Erik Simanis and Stuart Hart compare the original model with that of India-based Hindustan Unilever's model and point out a crucial difference.

Grameen Bank was a result of personal bond and shared vision between Nobel laureate Muhammad Yunus and Bangladeshi farmers/villagers. Yunus and the villagers spent quality time together as a community before the innovator launched the bank. While Grameen Bank became a profitable and scalable village bank, the authors say that Hindustan Unilever's project is "unlikely to grow into anything more than a new distribution channel." While Grameen Bank generated a "groundswell" of demand," Hindustan Unilver's entrepreneur turnov…

clinton/obama/media cabal to be exposed starting june14

A lot of people have surrendered themselves to be constantly duped by leftist media outlets.

The duped people now believe things that are entirely different from facts – as regards the obama/clinton/media cabal.

For the duped leftists, the coming Inspector General (IG) reports and follow-up actions (assuming they're both carried out unobstructed) will be a shock.

The shock will be so powerful, the duped leftists may react in insane and dangerous ways. (Well, they've already been behaving in such ways, but they've been doing so for a different set of reasons and largely unaware of facts.)

Broadly, the IG reports are going to be about treasonous/ unconstitutional/ illegal activities, power abuses, and obstructions for the purpose of:

1. Exonerating a criminal Hillary

2. Covering up the crimes of the Clinton folks

3. Attempts to block a presidential candidate

4. Attempts at a coup against a constitutionally elected president

5. Obstruction of presidential duties

6. Public deception…

Elon's April 1 tweets: part of an emerging leadership style?

First his tweets and then my comments ...

Tesla Goes Bankrupt
Palo Alto, California, April 1, 2018 -- Despite intense efforts to raise money, including a last-ditch mass sale of Easter Eggs, we are sad to report that Tesla has gone completely and totally bankrupt. So bankrupt, you can't believe it. — Elon Musk (@elonmusk) April 1, 2018
There are many chapters of bankruptcy and, as critics so rightly pointed out, Tesla has them *all*, including Chapter 14 and a half (the worst one). — Elon Musk (@elonmusk) April 1, 2018
Elon was found passed out against a Tesla Model 3, surrounded by "Teslaquilla" bottles, the tracks of dried tears still visible on his cheeks.

This is not a forward-looking statement, because, obviously, what's the point?

Happy New Month! pic.twitter.com/YcouvFz6Y1 — Elon Musk (@elonmusk) April 1, 2018
Almost all commenters appear to love Elon's April 1 tweets. But one person commented "CEOs of public companies shouldn't be putting out tw…