Skip to main content

Transient advantage in, Sustainable advantage out?


I pre-ordered and read the book, The End of Competitive Advantage. Author Rita McGrath presented the "Leading change" program I attended at Columbia Business School in 2008. More interestingly, among the companies she researched for the book, my former employer Cognizant is at the top of the list (and I had spent 11 years there)!

The book is about a strategy that is already getting into business dictionaries: transient advantage (versus sustainable advantage, which is what Porter and others taught us).

"From the many global cases discussed (one of them is my former employer), it is clear that transient advantage is increasingly used to achieve business growth and success. Professor McGrath not only shares transient principles with LEADERS, but – importantly – provides information that can help EMPLOYEES to prepare for successful careers in organizations that use transient principles." The preceding is a copy/paste of my review at
The book largely represents a company's perspective – how to use transient advantage as a strategy for growth even in difficult times. That's good and I agree with the argument. What I'd also like to see going forward (and this could come from other researchers) is:
  • What is the impact on customers? How does the transient approach change the value and experience customers receive?
  • What is the impact on employees? The book does say how employees should change, using very desirable analogies such as Olympians, but what do employees think? What do they feel about the change experience?
But don't wait for these details, start with Prof Rita's book!


Popular posts from this blog

Explorer mentality Vs conqueror mentality

A fixation on competitors and on beating them is evidence of what Amazon's Jeff Bezos calls a conqueror mentality. In contrast, people waking up in the morning thinking how to innovate for the customer -- and having intense fun innovating -- is evidence of an explorer mentality.

The explorer mentality resulted in Amazon allowing negative reviews of its products. Reacting to this, a book publisher objected, saying "You make money when you sell things." But Bezos thought, "We don't make money when we sell things; we make money when we help customers make purchase decisions." So explorer mentality also demands a willingness to be misunderstood for long periods of time.

During his 16 years as CEO, Bezos' Amazon has delivered shareholder returns of 12,266% (industry-adjusted), and the company's value has grown by $111 billion. More in HBR Jan-Feb 2013.

M&A perspective: IT staffing Vs IT consulting

This report is a simple analysis by HT Capital -- a boutique investment banking firm in New York. It basically makes the point that being a staffing company (Vs consulting company) does not provide adequate returns to most investors, especially from an M&A perspective.

Peter Rozsa, co-author of the report, is a Senior Managing Director at HT Capital. He was also my "classmate" at a Columbia Business School executive education program. I have Peter's permission to make the report available here.

Click to download PDF report.

Leading Change Vs. "Leading" Status Quo

Change and Status quo can be as far apart from each other as a butterfly is from a caterpillar ...

Or ... as an is from a K-Mart ... Or ... as a BMW is from a Hyundai ... Or ... as laying a runway is from paving a cow path ... Or ... as a solution is from a product ... Or ... as experience is from service ... Or ... as customer success is from customer satisfaction ... Or ... as a distinct brand-you is from a me-too employee ...

Change can be triggered by innovation. Change can happen in corporate culture. And so on. There is a leader "behind" every Change. If you consider the corporate world, people like Lou Gerstner, Michael Dell, and Jack Welch may come to mind. Actually, there are scores of other lesser-known and unknown leaders that make change happen in their organizations.

Here's my question: What are some differences between those who lead change and those who "lead" the Status quo? Oh yes, we know about the staggering percentage of Change i…